District 9 (2009)

Geoff Berkshire of Metromix called District 9 "a late summer sleeper that puts most of Hollywood to shame." Alan Smithee would like to agree, but as soon as this film began, a man in a nearby seat began discussing it loudly with his wife (or possibly daughter) in a sociopathic fashion, causing Alan Smithee to lose focus.

After moving back several rows in the theater (the only effective way to avoid loud talkers), Alan Smithee became engrossed in an early scene involving the eviction of aliens from their blighted township. The scene so engrossed the young couple behind Alan Smithee that they felt compelled to discuss it. They used whispers, but still.

After another move, Alan Smithee tried to reengage with the film, but a young man in the row ahead began texting someone on a device with a rather large and bright screen. This is of course against theater policy (as well as rude), but young people never worry about how their behavior affects others (or themselves). By shifting one seat over, Alan Smithee managed to remove the texting device from his sight line.

The film seemed compelling, but Alan Smithee can't be sure until he's seen it in its entirety without some motherfucker opening his fat mouth. Will keep readers updated.

Two Independent films

Lars and the Real Girl (2007) received some good reviews, but Alan Smithee was afraid it would be too precious, so he avoided it. But Lars looked good enough for Alan Smithee to put in his Netflix queue, especially when he couldn't think of anything else.

When Lars works, it works because of Ryan Gosling's unwinking performance. It is at its best when the townspeople take Lars' Real Girl seriously as his girlfriend. But scenes such as one in which the Real Girl reads a story to a class of children border on the quirky and threaten to derail the central conceit. Ultimately, the film holds it together and, most importantly, entertains. Plus the doll was hot.


(500) Days of Summer (2009) received uniformly good reviews, which only demonstrates the biases of film critics. Structurally, the film is interesting. Alan Smithee admits to being predisposed to enjoying anything with Zooey Deschanel, but this film managed to make her creepy. Her Summer Finn would make Alan Smithee run very far away in search of anyone else. I blame the script, because I'm not capable of blaming Zooey, and because it was the script.

The film's message, that there's one Special Someone out there for each of us, may be true, but do we really want our films to have messages?

Knowing (2009)

Alan Smithee has a high tolerance for hokum in science fiction films. Knowing starts compellingly, with a creepy/cute elementary school student fifty years in the past who scribbles strings of numbers on a sheet of paper. Enter modern day physics professor John Koestler (Nicolas Cage), who sees the paper and deciphers the pattern. Turns out Koestler has some world-saving to do, and Cage's patented hysteria is perfect for the role.

Koestler spends the middle section of the film trying to prevent various disasters, to mildly entertaining effect. But then things go horribly wrong. Alan Smithee was willing to ignore the fact that the bad guys (or are they good guys?) look like members of a German techno band. He was willing to ignore the superfluous biblical references that attempt to infuse the film with metaphysical import. But he could not ignore the ludicrous and profoundly unsatisfactory resolution, topped by a final shot that perhaps the filmmakers thought would warm viewer's hearts but which Alan Smithee found puzzling and terrifying.

Alan Smithee recommends you catch this one on cable and, after the scene in the subway, change the channel to anything else.

Nicolas Cage's Professor John Koestler meets the techno band

Up (2009)

At the urging of an acquaintance, Alan Smithee attended a showing of Up in Disney Digital 3D. The acquaintance praised the impressiveness of the 3D effect, which is created digitally, unlike with 3D films of old, such as The Tingler (1959).

Alan Smithee was wildly entertained, but he is unsure what percentage of the effect was due to imaginative storytelling and what percentage to the 3D effect. It certainly made action sequences come alive. If only one could apply a digital 3D effect to certain life experiences, perhaps they might not be so soul-deadeningly dull.

The experience was worth $15, especially when you remember that one day you will be dead, and $15 can't change that.

Pecker (1998)

As Alan Smithee gets older, he realizes that there are only a handful of contemporary American directors who have a distinctive voice that one can identify in their films and that can be satisfying in way that is independent of the other qualities of a film. Some examples are Woody Allen and Robert Altman, as well as younger directors like Wes Anderson and Todd Solondz.

John Waters is a distinctive comedic voice, and with Pecker, he reined in some of his more camp tendencies and made what Alan Smithee feels is his most satisfying film. Here's a classic Watersian comic moment: Pecker is an amateur photographer who makes it big in the New York art world. When his girlfriend Shelley catches him kissing the gallery owner, she screams "I hate modern photography!" Alan Smithee has observed that even those weaned on modern Hollywood comedies are capable of understanding and enjoying Pecker. And for those with some discernment, it satisfies.

Alan Smithee finds that re-viewing the work of the aforementioned directors brings him comfort as he ages. The world around him grows increasingly more generic, but their voices remain undiluted. They are American treasures.

City of Ember (2008)

Movies made from books face the challenge of being true to the original story while still succeeding as movies. Usually, they are most successful when they jettison those parts of the story that do not serve the film. The astonishing Lemony Snicket's A Series of Unfortunate Events (2004) distilled events from the first three books in the Snicket series into a wildly entertaining film that inexplicably did not win the hearts of the millions of youngsters who read the books.

City of Ember begins compellingly; within minutes, you are absorbed in the story and its characters (all well-played, with Bill Murray relaxed and playful). An early scene in which the young citizens of Ember are assigned their jobs perfectly captures the look and feel of the imaginary world. And the film manages to sustain nearly this same level of interest for another hour, give or take.

The final third of the film, however, devolves into a play-by-play of the children's escape. And when they are finally free, a moment that should inspire awe passes so quickly that the credits are rolling before the viewer has taken it in. At only 90 minutes, the film could easily have taken five or ten more minutes to satisfactorily conclude. A missed opportunity, but still worth seeing.

Ten (2002)

Alan Smithee is aware that what The Man tells us about the country of Iran does not square with what he knows of Iran from the films of Abbas Kiarostami, Mohsen Makhmalbaf, Jafar Panahi, and others. A viewing of Kiarostami's Ten (2002) should be enough to throw doubt on The Man's current characterization of Iran. Americans in particular should be wary when anyone equates the character of a nation with the policies of its government.

The film captures ten conversations between a female driver in Tehran and the passengers in her car. No one is chasing her and nothing explodes. There is no nudity. The soundtrack contains no Indie pop. A voiceover is not present to explain things. You will have to do some paying attention and maybe some thinking with this one.

Yes, the entire film takes place in a single day inside one woman's car, but why should that stop you from watching it? New and different things can be scary, but Alan Smithee knows you can do it!

The Brown Bunny (2003)

Alan Smithee used to have a DVD player that allowed him to view films in fast forward with sound. It was perfect for the obligatory music video segment that is part of almost every movie made since 1990. It also converted The Brown Bunny from 93 minutes of tedium into a mildly entertaining 46.5 minute film.

Vincent Gallo directed the wonderful Buffalo '66 (1998); if you haven't seen it, Alan Smithee recommends you rent it now, then return here and read the rest of this review. Mr. Gallo made it clear in interviews that he thought an awful lot of himself, and when The Brown Bunny was poorly reviewed, he quit filmmaking to adore himself privately.

At standard speed, Alan Smithee must agree that The Brown Bunny is not a very good film. In double time, however, it ain't half bad. Interminable scenes of Bud (Gallo) riding his motorcycle become merely a little long, and perhaps even create the meditative rhythm that Mr Gallo was trying for. The ending is still unnecessarily graphic (and ludicrous), but it lasts half as long.

Alan Smithee wishes he could remember the model number of that DVD player for those who wish to recreate the experience described above. It might have been a Toshiba.

Last Chance Harvey (2008)

Over the last few years, Dustin Hoffman has been quietly giving some of the best performances of his career. As the mob boss in Confidence (2003), he was sinister in new and delightful ways. He was a big part of what made viewers give in to the delicious nonsense of I ♥ Huckabees (2004). And in the titular role in Mr. Magorium's Wonder Emporium (2007) he was playful and eminently entertaining. So Alan Smithee came into Last Chance Harvey with high hopes. The film has problems, but it is still much better than one might suspect.

The first half hour deftly depicts just how disappointing and humiliating life is for most people, most of the time. In the central love story, Hoffman and Emma Thompson play off each other well, and though Alan Smithee isn't sure he ever quite believed them as a couple, he cannot deny he was entertained. Refreshingly, the film takes place in a world much closer to the real one than to the world of Romantic Comedy. One example: both main characters have normal jobs just like real people; there are no architects, fashion designers, writers, or art gallery owners in the entire film!

The film is in "limited release," which in this case means it is playing in just 16 theaters, because movies are a business, and no one wants to see a movie about old people. Luckily, Alan Smithee lives in a large metropolis in which four of those theaters are located. Readers are encouraged to add it their Netflix queue (Availability Unknown).

Serendipity (2001)

This film is part of Alan Smithee's voluminous Christmas movie collection; any film in which one or more scenes take place during the Christmas season can gain admission into the collection, provided the film also fills one with Christmas spirit, and provided one can follow the story after a large glass of wine.

Serendipity stars the always likeable John Cusack, as well as Kate Beckinsale, just six years after her magnificence in Cold Comfort Farm (1995). After a ludicrous set-up, the film settles into a long and satisfying middle section, which entertains in large part because of supporting players Jeremy Piven, Molly Shannon, and the delicious but large-headed John Corbett. Shannon and Piven, as the best friends of the two main characters, nearly steal the film, which turns conventional in the final act. I usually plan my alcohol inhalation so that I am unconscious by the final scenes, which play out much as one would suspect.

Those who live in New York City can visit Serendipity the restaurant, from which the film takes its name, and witness the line of tourists waiting outside in the cold for a table. Why? Because it was in a movie. It truly is the darkest age of Man.

Happy-Go-Lucky (2008)

Alan Smithee rarely sees a film that makes him think. This is partly because most films aren't trying to say anything (or they're trying, but failing), and partly because Alan Smithee only has a short window of time each day during which he can do heavy thinking, to wit, the period beginning after his morning coffee kicks in up until the time when he needs to go down for his nap.

Even with limited time to think, Alan Smithee understood that Happy-Go-Lucky is not "an exuberant comedy," and the main character, Poppy, does not have "an innate effervescence that plays off beautifully against adversity." (Entertainment Weekly)

Something else is going on. The viewer gets to know Poppy by watching how she handles different situations. Though she is "happy-go-lucky," she still has to be an adult in the world, and the viewer can almost see her making decisions at crucial moments. The film fascinates because, to borrow from Flannery O'Connor, everything is rendered, nothing is told.

The critics have praised Sally Hawkins' performance, but take note of the uniformly excellent work by all the supporting players. Alan Smithee fell in love a little bit with Poppy's relatively jaded roommate Zoe, but he is almost fully recovered now.

Tropic Thunder (2008)

Just when Alan Smithee thought Tom Cruise was irrelevant - his last palatable performance was John Anderton in Minority Report (2002) - he dons a fat suit and generates some of the most memorable comic moments in Tropic Thunder. Alan Smithee laughed hard when Cruise's Les Grossman finished a video conference and screeched at his assistant "Diet Coke!" The seductive dance he does for Matthew McConaughey's Rick Peck was so entertaining that he reprised it for the credit roll. For sheer gonads, the performance ranks with his inspired turn as motivational speaker Frank Mackey in the otherwise ludicrous Magnolia (1999).

It's easy to forget when watching Ben Stiller, Jack Black (and others) how good they are at what they do. The public tends to get bored with actors if they don't up the ante after a while. So the film, while very funny in parts, doesn't feel funny enough. A scene in which Robert Downey Jr. analyzes Ben Stiller's acting as he is being forced to perform for his captors is so clever, it makes one realize what is missing from much of the rest of the film. Still, with this many great actors all doing excellent work, one cannot say one didn't get one's $9 worth ($11.00 in New York City).

And while Alan Smithee thought Robert Downey Jr.'s performance as an African American platoon leader was inspired, the things he said were often not that funny.

A Short Film by Alan Smithee (2008)

for D. Chedwick Bryant

Written, Produced and Directed by Alan Smithee
From an idea by Alan Smithee
Cinematography: Alan Smithee
Editing: Alan Smithee
Set Decoration: Alan Smithee
Unit Manager: Alan Smithee
Costume Design: Alan Smithee (gowns)
Music: "Melancholia" by Edward Kennedy Ellington

Bad Movies

There are certain movies that They always cite as examples of "bad movies," and Ishtar (1987) gets mentioned more than any other. Yet I remember liking Ishtar when I first saw it. I re-watched it a few years ago, in case I was high the first time, and despite a bit too much tomfoolery, and the inclusion of a Superfluous Love Interest, it still entertains. The leads (Dustin Hoffman and Warren Beatty) play off each other well, and the "bad" songs (by Paul Williams) are the best part of the film. Writer/Director Elaine May said it best: "If all of the people who hate Ishtar had seen it, I would be a rich woman today."


Anything Else (2003) was panned by many critics who were put off by Jason Biggs' and Christina Ricci's impersonations of Woody Allen and Diane Keaton, respectively. But, once, when Alan Smithee found himself stuck waiting for someone in a strange apartment in New York City, he read the only book he could find, "Tuesdays With Morrie." Anything Else is the only antidote to that book he has ever found. Jerry (Biggs) receives advice from father-figure David (Woody Allen), except the advice is always terrible. Hilarity ensures.


As long as we are discussing good bad movies, Alan Smithee would like to mention a bad good movie. Saving Private Ryan (1998), which was very well reviewed, was as emotionally manipulative a film as has ever been made. You can see the calculation in every scene, and as a result, the film is awfully predictable (or maybe that was because we'd seen some of the scenes before, in Full Metal Jacket and other films). Many veterans of D-Day remarked how realistic Saving Private Ryan was, which only proves that realistic films are not necessarily good ones. Spielberg has always been a master technician, and he has occasionally used his talent to stunning effect (as in Minority Report (2005)). But this film is an insult to the viewer's intelligence.

The Dark Knight (2008)

The reviews for The Dark Knight were uniformly good, something that always makes Alan Smithee suspicious. Film reviewers also tend to overpraise any performance when it's an actor's last. All this left us unsure how to proceed: is the film good or no?

Alan Smithee is here to tell you: don't be afraid, the film is good. Heath Ledger's performance is not the life-changing event the reviewers claim, but it is very good, and very entertaining. The action sequences, especially the capturing of a Bad Guy from an office building, are tons of fun, and if Alan Smithee had fun, then just about any unmedicated person will.

The film has an odd tendency to cut away from the action, especially violent action. Perhaps this was how it managed its PG-13 rating. But overall, it is very well-made. There is some very effective cross-cutting that creates tension at key moments, and all the actors do excellent work.

The best part: TDK is over 2 1/2 hours long. For those who, like Alan Smithee, are desperately seeking a moment's relief from their miserable existence, it's like an extra hour's break from the brain's relentless jabbering for the price of a regular ticket!

Penelope (2006)

Penelope is another well-made, well-acted film that only needed a much better script. The idea was a good one - Penelope has a pig nose and no one will love/marry her and lift her curse. She sets off to see the world and finds that she only ever needed to love herself. Sounds good, right?

Two problems: one, when Penelope finally learns to love herself, her reward is: she gets a normal nose. Huh? This mixed message brought to you by writer Leslie Caveny ("Everybody Loves Raymond"); two, Christina Ricci looks absolutely adorable with a pig nose. Alan Smithee almost freeze-framed his DVD and kissed his TV screen. Who wouldn't want to marry that?

Some pluses: Reese Witherspoon and Peter Dinklage are both excellent, and the art direction is fantastic. Still, you might want to get out some knitting or start a filing project while watching this one. Best of luck.

Persepolis (2007)

Alan Smithee is aware that what The Man tells us about the country of Iran does not square with what he knows of Iran from the films of Abbas Kiarostami, Mohsen Makhmalbaf, Jafar Panahi, and others. A viewing of Kiarostami's Ten (2002) should be enough to throw doubt on The Man's current characterization of Iran. Americans in particular should be wary when anyone equates the character of a nation with the policies of its government.

Persepolis began as a "graphic novel," and it went a long way toward showing the gap between the values of Iranian people and their fundamentalist government. But where the cartoon was funny, touching, and educational, the film is preachy and confusing. And Marjane, the heroine of the book, comes across here as insufferable; she seems unable or unwilling to get along with anyone, and is disdainful of everyone except her immediate family.

The animation looks great, but that doesn't make Marjane any more likable.

Alan Smithee recommends you go see WALL·E (2008); if you've already seen it, then today would be a good day to stay sober and read Persepolis on the couch. It's worth it.

WALL·E (2008)

After Cars (2006) and Ratatouille (2007), this reviewer had almost given up on Pixar Animation Studios. Their first films (Toy Story I and II, A Bug's Life) were never less than entertaining, then with the wildly imaginative Monsters, Inc. (2001), they astonished. No one who saw Monsters emerged unchanged.

Finding Nemo (2003), and The Incredibles (2004) were a return to earlier form, but the latter day films have been Disneyesque and largely lame. Now comes WALL·E.

The film opens on a devastated earth some 700 years in the future. WALL·E the robot dwells there seemingly alone, and the early scenes beautifully depict his lonely existence. When a female robot named Eve arrives, WALL·E falls in love. Alan Smithee didn't find Eve particularly attractive - sure, she has a great personality, but she's shaped like an egg - but to each his own.

The good news is the film has stretches of Monsters-like brilliance, as well as an engrossing visual style. The story isn't particularly funny, but one hardly notices. Alan Smithee did not hear any children in the theater complaining, so WALL·E must somehow have captivated them without pop culture references, "humorous" sidekicks, or inane physical jokes. Perhaps things are getting better.

Go Orange!

Alan Smithee is honoring June 5th Go Orange! with a review of either A Clockwork Orange (1971) or Orange County (2002). Since much has been written about A Clockwork Orange, and since Alan Smithee has difficulty untangling ACO from his earliest memories of watching it illicitly on the Q Channel, failing to understand it, and noticing only the holes that were cut in a shirt to reveal part of a woman's breasts, he has decided to focus on Orange County instead.



Orange County, a just-okay teen comedy, featured the offspring of both Sissy Spacek and Tom Hanks, either because they are stunningly talented performers, or for some other reason known only to Hollywood insiders. Alan Smithee frankly can't remember Sissy Jr.'s performance, but she takes a nice 8 X 10 glossy. It is interesting to note that she has not continued in film, and recently began recording an album. It must be nice to have options.

Colin Hanks has not fared as well. He lacks some of his father's goodish looks, and much of his talent. He continues to get work, but not in anything you would have seen. But Alan Smithee wishes him well, for Tom's sake, and for the sake of all super-rich sons who live in the shadow of their fathers.

Iron Man (2008)

Alan Smithee couldn't give a crap about the Iron Man comic, and he is unfamiliar with the original story. He went to this movie solely because of his well-documented love of the performances of Mr. Robert Downey Jr.

Mr. Downey Jr. plays Tony Stark, a wealthy industrialist who - frankly, Alan Smithee didn't care. As long as Downey Jr. was on-screen, all was well. Gwyneth Paltrow, long a Smithee favorite, brings pizazz to her disappointingly small role, and director Jon Favreau keeps the action rolling swiftly along.

Iron Man is at its best when documenting Stark's construction and fine-tuning of his creation. The film culminates in an overlong battle between Iron Man and Who Cares that introduces the first moments of boredom to the film, but that was to be expected. Iron Man fans and those who fetishize special effects, however, will cream their jeans.

While giving Robert Downey Jr. a large amount of money is probably, in the long run, a bad idea, if the result is films like this, then Alan Smithee feels that sacrificing the life of one actor for the entertainment of millions is the right thing to do.

Made of Honor (2008)

Alan Smithee admits that his life right now is not scintillating. That explains why he prefers attending first run movies of questionable quality to whatever it is he does when he is not at the movies.

The critics said Made of Honor was a "cookie-cutter comedy," a predictable "paint by numbers" movie. They receive a generous salary for telling us what we already know. Romantic comedies are based on a tired formula, but some do entertain. We need to know if this is one of them.

Alan Smithee is here to tell you: it is not. "Made of Honor" is one of those double entendre titles that has no second entendre. Who or what is "made of honor" in the film? Answer: nothing. That should be a hint of the level of brainpower behind the script.

The actors are more than up to the task, and the film is well directed, but Alan Smithee found that it could not hold his attention, and he began to recall the details of his life outside the theater, precisely what he goes to the movies to forget.

Depressing, at best.

Charlie Wilson's War (2007)

We put this film in our Netflix queue before we saw Enchanted (2007) and fell deeply in love with Ms. Amy Adams, whom we like to refer to around the house as Amy Adams-Smithee. So we were surprised to see her here playing Congressman Wilson's administrative assistant. She is given little to do in the film, but that's okay, because Philip Seymour "How's the Peepin" Hoffman does enough entertaining for both of them, and Tom Hanks finally earns those Oscars he received for whatever crap he received them for. He breezes through this film, leaving in his wake pure entertainment.

Those who normally fear any project involving "writer" Aaron Sorkin need not worry. Either the original source material was so good as to be incorruptible, or Mr. Sorkin is improving, in which case there is hope for mankind.

Julia Roberts is adequate, as usual.

Atonement (2007)

M. Night Shyamalan's The Sixth Sense (1999) introduced a new kind of surprise ending to film, and since then, filmmakers, including Shyamalan himself, have attempted to duplicate it, with varying results. Remember the atrocious Identity (2003), in which the surprise ending was so lame that it succeeded in diminishing the entire film?

There have been numerous other failures. Atonement is not a failure, but it comes close. Before you object and say But Mr. Smithee, Sir, Atonement is based on a famous book, let me just say that I don't care. A film must stand on its own merits, if any.

The first act is intriguing; we see the same event from different points of view, and the film seems to be getting at some sort of truth. But the second act devolves into a Spielbergian technical exercise that, while never less than entertaining, does little to advance the story.

Then we get the surprise ending, in which the meta-story is chosen over the story. The move is supposed to elicit emotions, whereas to this viewer, it felt more like a cheap trick. We feel a sense of loss, but mostly for the film that never was.


The filmmaker's attempt to make Romola Garai look plain also fails miserably, much to the viewer's delight.

2 Days in Paris (2007)

After Before Sunrise (1995) and Before Sunset (2004), Alan Smithee got the impression that Julie Delpy was interesting. With 2 Days in Paris, which she also wrote and directed, she demonstrates otherwise.

The film opens with an annoying couple (Marion and Jack) trying to hail a taxi. Almost immediately, one doesn't care. Then, just as one is preparing to press eject, the pair arrives at Marion's parents', and the film suddenly entertains. A sister arrives shortly after, and the ensuing scenes at Marion's house are the best in the film.

Unfortunately, Delpy miscalculates. The film follows the couple around Paris, to the dismay of all. We are supposed to be learning something about love, but in case we aren't, Delpy provides a voice-over, where we are told, among other things, that breaking up "hurts so much." You get the idea.

The entertaining parents are played by Delpy's actual parents, both actors, and one presumes they were not consulted during the editing process.

Miss Pettigrew Lives for a Day (2008)

Sometimes we go to a film because we have a thing for the star. Alan Smithee is only human. After Enchanted (2007), was it really possible for a grown man to think about anything other than Amy Adams? Also, could that man be expected to refrain from daydreaming about meeting and wooing Ms. Adams (provided he has finally gotten a job and a haircut)? Alan Smithee won't pretend to understand what floats other men's boats; he can only say that love of the kind he has found with Ms. Adams in his imagination is rare indeed.

As for the film, with an excellent script and so many fine actors, one must fault the director for the flatness of the picture. Mr. Nalluri's last outing was the made-for-TV Tsunami: The Aftermath (2006), both nights of which Alan Smithee watched, which gives you an idea of how fulfilling life is in the Smithee household.

The Oscar Pre-show

The "news" at this year's Oscar pre-show, according to Access Hollywood, The Boston Herald, and other sources, was Gary Busey's "wacko" and "berserk" behavior on the red carpet. Alan Smithee finds it interesting that it is considered normal for actors to wait in a line to be interviewed by a television personality with no apparent knowledge of movies primarily to plug the names of clothing and jewelry designers and answer inane questions about their pregnancies, while it is considered odd or "unnerving" to ignore the artificiality of the event and hug people.

Gary Busey has always been enthusiastic, and he has never pretended to be like everyone else. If he had recently starred in a major motion picture, his behavior probably would have been laughed off. What Hollywood really can't abide is actors who step out of their place, who won't simply disappear when they aren't needed.

Alan Smithee Selects the Best Films of the Year and Then Lists Them One After Another

One of the best films of last year - whatever year it was - was Enchanted. Amy Adams astonished, especially when imitating the movements of cartoon ladies, but she never had a chance at an Oscar nomination. Critics are not permitted to praise films of this type too highly, whereas they creamed their jeans over Dreamgirls (technically 2006), a musical composed largely of unlistenable songs.

Zodiac astonished in its willingness to take its time and tell a story. Even the presence of pretty boy Jake Gyllenhaal did not detract from this masterful film that was released too early in the year to receive any nominations.

No Country for Old Men didn't make any sense, but it was beautiful to look at and enthralling from beginning to end. Alan Smithee would have excised Woody Harrelson and made it a slightly better film, but no one asked.

The Simpson's Movie. Critics said it was just like a long episode of the TV show. Perfect.

National Treasure: Book of Secrets wanted nothing more than to give you your money's worth. You weren't likely to have any serious thoughts during this movie but, like Raiders of the Lost Ark(1981), you were entertained in a quite silly way. The critics largely made fun of it, because they are so very very sophisticated.

Across the Universe was also thoroughly entertaining from beginning to end. Some confusedly thought it was attempting to realistically portray the 1960's, and so they refused to enjoy themselves. And in a surprise move, Bono demonstrated that he could be entertaining.

Eastern Promises boasted the best performance by an actor last year, Viggo Mortensen playing whomever he played. Go see.

(And in case you're counting, Zodiac: 0 Oscar nominations, Norbit: 1 nomination)

Broken English (2007)

Here's one I rented solely because Parker Posey appeared in it, which has always been sufficient reason to watch a film in the past. I would otherwise never have discovered the astonishing Josie and the Pussycats (2001).

Besides Posey's adorable-enough character Nora, there is unlikeable movie star/one night stand Nick (Justin Theroux), unpleasant best friend Audrey (Drea de Matteo), and unwatchable French love interest Julien (Who Cares). The viewer is supposed to root for Nora to throw caution to the wind and fly to Paris to find Julien, whereas I could never get past his hat.

It seems the only cure for American neuroticism is the happy-go-lucky romanticism of the French. Fortunately, flights to and from Paris can be booked, canceled, and rebooked, as whim dictates, for apparently modest cost, at least if this film is to be believed.

For fans of Parker Posey only, and even then, bring a book.

Jesse Stone: Death in Paradise (2006)

Recently, when Alan Smithee was recovering from food poisoning (again), he happened upon a Magnum, P.I. (1980-1988) Marathon on cable TV. After watching several episodes, he remarked this isn't nearly as lame as I remember! Tom Selleck was always entertaining, but with the Jesse Stone movies, he surprises by being genuinely interesting.

Stone Cold (2005) was an above-average TV movie with Selleck subdued and occasionally menacing. But Jesse Stone: Night Passage (2006) astonished. Bleak and unrelenting, JSNP was better than several theatrical films Alan Smithee has seen of late, though he has not yet been to Ratatouille (2007).

Jesse Stone: Death in Paradise, then, was a step backward. Selleck is credited as a co-writer, and he demonstrated why good films use professional writers. His Jesse Stone had stopped drinking, and he was far less interesting for it. Alan Smithee began to wonder if all involved were unaware what was interesting about the first two films.

A viewing of Jesse Stone: Sea Change (2007) should determine the direction the franchise is heading. Night Passage may not be as great as I remember. Perhaps I simply had too much cough syrup again.

Little Children (2006)

Little Children, like American Beauty (1999) before it, thinks it has something really deep to say about modern suburban life: things are not as they seem, there's something sinister just underneath the surface, etc., etc., etc. But without Kevin Spacey to entertain, all that remains is the unpleasantness and the contrivances.

Critics responded to the film's patina of seriousness, ignoring its conventional plot and heavy-handed symbolism. Meanwhile, they panned masterpieces like Sky High (2005), one of the best films of the '00s, simply because it is about a high school for teen superheroes.

And though Alan Smithee has admired Jackie Earle Haley since his unaffected performance in Breaking Away (1979), viewers should also take notice of Noah Emmerich's portrayal of the disgraced policeman. Astonishing.

Zodiac (2007)

Alan Smithee has written here before about his appreciation of the film performances of Mr. Robert Downey Jr. If Zodiac has a weakness, it is the too-early departure of Mr. Downey from the film.

To its teaspoon of Downey, Zodiac adds a full cup the delicious Mark Ruffalo and subtracts three heaping tablespoons of Jake Gyllenhaal who, though not a Smithee favorite, is used to not wholly unpleasant effect.

If, like Alan Smithee, you feel you just can't go on, pop into the theater for a matinee of Zodiac. 2 1/2 hours later, you may not even remember that you had completely lost your way.

The Da Vinci Code (2006)

Alan Smithee did not read the book of the same name, yet he could follow the basic story of the secret organization fighting to protect Jesus' offspring (played by the always pointless Audrey Tatou).

The film plays like a longer, slightly less plausible version of National Treasure (2004). The latter is the better film: more compact, more clever, and more entertaining.

At 149 minutes, however, TDVC provides at least thirty extra minutes of reality-free living. That alone makes it a four star film in Alan Smithee's book.

Bus 174 (2002)

In case you haven't heard enough bad news, Bus 174 is here to tell you 1. the streets of Brazil are filled with homeless children, and 2. the police occasionally open fire on them in groups, and 3. when they are sleeping on the streets, people will drop paving stones on their heads and smoosh their skulls. Good times.

Apparently, one of the street kids who did not get shot or smooshed took a bus full of people hostage one day. He used the opportunity to bring attention to the plight of the homeless, but the general population was not ready for his message. After his capture, the crowd rushed in to exact revenge. The police fended them off, but only so they could suffocate him in the privacy of their squad car.

But in this, the Holiday season, Alan Smithee is quick to note that Brazil does not have a corner on poverty and racism. Now, what's on Lifetime?

Bad Day at Black Rock (1955)

A bunch of small town hotheads get themselves worked up after the bombing of Pearl Harbor and kill the local Japanese-American farmer. Four years later, a one-armed army vet named Macreedy (Spencer Tracy) shows up in town, and the hotheads worry he might discover their secret. They try to run him off, but he don't scare so easy, see. Tough guy Coley (Ernest Borgnine) turns to violence, but one-arm gives him an ass-kicking unlike any other on film. It satisfies.

This is a must-see film. Alan Smithee is embarrassed that he hasn't appreciated Mr. Tracy's work enough, when really he should be more embarrassed about the fact that he hasn't had a steady job in over two years.

Should be watched with beer on hand, as usual.

Fa yeung nin wa (2000)

A beautifully shot, gorgeously produced film that lacks only a story AKA a reason to care. The clever construction of the film does hold some interest, but as a human, Alan Smithee enjoys films about the human experience - any part of it. Yes, the two main characters fall in love in the rain, and if I was nineteen, I know that would feel very very important to me. But us grownups like a little content to our story.

It should probably be seen in the theater, where one can relish its beauty. On DVD, it plays best in fast forward.

The Illusionist (2006)

Those of us in the know were watching Seventh Heaven long before it was recognized as the greatest unintentional satire on television. We therefore watched Jessica Biel grow from a horsey 14-year old to the girl who sat in a sink in her underwear for Gear magazine.

Well, apparently sitting in sinks in your underwear gets motion picture deals. Ms. Biel, playing Sophie, draws from her meager talents to, surprisingly, not stink up the screen. Edward Norton does his Edward Norton thing to great effect, and Paul Giamatti makes us forget he is Paul Giamatti - no small feat.

The film botches only the ending by explaining everything, then explaining it some more, then some more, then checking to see if we got it.

The History of Tom Jones, a Foundling (1997)

Max Beesley, who went on to glory in the astonishing Glitter (2001), first honed his craft as Tom Jones in this 300 minute BBC production. Alan Smithee currently isn't working, so he has plenty of time to watch 300 minute productions of all kinds.

A young Samantha Morton appears as Sophia Western, and though this was before she turned all weird, there are early signs. Witness the frightening and inexplicable guttural screaming with which she twice surprises the viewer (and, we presume, the director).

One of the more interesting things one learns watching this production is that the woman Tom loves pronounces her name "Sew-fie-yah."

Enjoyable, particularly for those with no other sources of joy in their lives.

Final Destination 3 (2006)

Final Destination (2000) was groundbreaking if only in that it introduced in its plot a new reason for killing teenagers: They were supposed to die in a plane crash, but they didn't. Now Death is angry/confused/resorting to mathematical formulae. FD3 is a shameless reworking of earlier moods, but it's still better than Cold Mountain.

Yes, it asks us to believe that the human body is composed largely of red goo with a soft outer shell that bursts on impact, but what wonderful things result from such a belief! Our intrepid heroes, who are trying desperately to warn the others, keep witnessing their deaths, and, in the process, get repeatedly splattered with the gooey insides of their multicultural friends. (It is true - we are all the same on the inside!) It's vaguely pornographic, and it satisfies.

Inasmuch as this reviewer thinks about his death, he can't help thinking that a quick, splattery head-smooshing wouldn't be a bad way to go. This film gives him hope.

Kiss Kiss Bang Bang (2005)

Remember Robert Downey Jr. in the revelatory Wonder Boys (which, like 2005's Thank You for Smoking, contained superfluous Katie Holmes)? Like Steve Zahn or Sam Rockwell, he made you wish he would get more work.

Well, he got more work, and as Harry Lockhart, Mr. Downey astonishes. Maybe it's all that Mexican Black Tar heroin and Wing Chun Kung Fu, but Downey's line readings are unlike any in the industry.

Val Kilmer departs from his usual roll playing Val Kilmer to play a gay private investigator - not much of a stretch for him - and he finally entertains.

Shane Black, who after writing nine crappy films, must have locked himself in a room with some clever friends for a weekend, because the dialogue is a huge improvement from "Aww, man, fat kid farted!" (The Monster Squad (1987)).

It's the perfect antidote to the committee-made films of the past year.

Syriana (2005)

If, like me, you assume that our government is up to no good all over the world - hasn't that been obvious ever since Missing (1982) - then you will be predisposed to enjoy Syriana. After all, it is through the movies that we have learned the truth about the CIA-Mafia-Masonic-Nazi shadow government of last 30 years.

But the real accomplishment of Syriana is that it manages to hold your interest while being far too complicated to understand. And George Clooney has gotten better and better ever since he started holding his head still.

It's better than another evening of watching America's Got Talent and weeping.

Aquamarine (2006)

Someone on glue praised this movie in Variety magazine, and I believed them and rented the DVD. The "stars," Emma Roberts, JoJo Levesque and Sara Paxton, are apparently well known to tweens. All three have their own television serieses and multiple CD releases, unbeknownst to everyone over the age of 12.

The movie basically blows. Two girls find a mermaid. Hilarity ensues. Mss. Levesque and Roberts display their modest talents, while receiving no help from the screenplay.

Two pluses: Sara Paxton, as the mermaid Aquamarine, gives a spirited performance, and I didn't think about the emptiness of existence and my eventual annihilation for 98 minutes!

Take a Vicodin twenty minutes before viewing and it will seem like it matters.

Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire (2005)

This movie doesn't so much suck as blow. Perhaps I should have seen it in the theater; on a standard 4:3 television, the image is the size of a business envelope. I suspect that on the big screen, the look of the film partially makes up for the boring, Harry-centric story, the lackluster performances, and the dragon-bashing.

Kids will love it, of course, but then kids love when you fall down or someone farts. Avoid at all costs.

"The Hardy Boys/Nancy Drew Mysteries" (1977-78)

Sometimes we rent a DVD of a film or television show that we know is not important or accomplished simply because it evokes memories for us. Old sensations return and we feel young again.

Pamela Sue Martin gave me such a hard-on as a teenager that I had to put The Hardy Boys/Nancy Drew Mysteries in my Netflix queue as soon as I received the email alert that it had been released.

This girl could solve mysteries with the best of the boys. She didn't take any guff, which was a huge turn-on for those small boys who love powerful yet incredibly hot women.

A review is beside the point. I assume the stories will be contrived and the production quality will be mediocre. But the boners will be hard and lasting.

The Courtship of Eddie's Father - Dramedy or Comeda

Courtship used a standard formula (Mother eaten by wolves, Father must find new mate or surrender child to the authorities), but it blended comedy and drama and had the inimitable Bill Bixby (later of Hulk), who added just the right lightness to the role of unrealistically perfect father.

Those of us who grew up watching the show know that Courtship helped children in thousands of single-parent homes cope with the raw deal they had gotten. They could watch Bixby and say to themselves Jesus I wish our Dad talked about what he was going through instead of just lying in his bed all day.

Courtship is still not available on DVD, but you can help by writing and mailing one postcard every day of your life until you die to:

ABC TELEVISION CENTER STUDIOS
4151 Prospect Avenue,
Hollywood, CA

Hogan's Heroes (1965-1971) Season Three

What more can be said about Hogan's that hasn't been said already by admiring reviewers around the globe? This dramedy was so innovative that psychologists are still debating the subtext of many Klink/Hogan interchanges.

Hogan's makes us ask How does humor help one cope with confinement? and Is homosexuality caused by a single gene or will any two guys do it if they're locked up together long enough, especially if one of them is LeBeau?

Leave the place you are at now, rent this DVD set and watch the entire season straight through. You'll thank me.

The Sorrow and the Pity (Le Chagrin et la pitié, 1969)

The last time Germany tried to take over the world, they made the French look really bad by winning The Battle of France in, like, two days. The French responded by making a documentary about it 25 years later.

Honestly, I thought I knew this era, but this film gave me an education. Here's the deal: when it comes to the French Occupation, everyone is guilty. Regular people are guilty of not joining the Resistance. Those in the Resistance are guilty of joining just to look good. Nazis are guilty of sucking.

So if you're looking for a big comedown of a film in which it turns out everyone has done the wrong thing, this is your baby. And get out your darning, because this bitch is over four hours long!


"Hitler, you totally rock! Thanks for invading our country!"

The Rockford Files

Season One of The Rockford Files (1974) is now out on DVD, which means it's time to take some sick days at work, drop the pets off at the kennel and sit down for some serious viewing.

The first thing you wonder as the DVD disappears into the player is Will Rockford compare with my memory of it? Episode One (The Kirkoff Case) begins, and you notice that James Garner is a little dumpier and more pear-shaped than you remembered. However, the show still astonishes.

What can one say? The concept is brilliant; Not until Trapper John MD (1979) would another TV character live in a trailer in a parking lot. The dialogue is some of the best ever filmed. Though the early episodes include protracted car chases, one only has to remember that James Garner allegedly did all his own driving for the show and the excitement returns.

Work can wait. Rent this today.

In Her Shoes (2005)

Sometimes we feel guilty if we don't take advantage of our Netflix subscription DVD rental service, and so we watch films even when we can no longer remember how they got in our queue. We just want to get our money's worth.

Such was the case with In Her Shoes. This is the film that asks us to believe that Toni Collette is fat and ugly and that Cameron Diaz is Jewish. It also asks us to believe that someone who looks like Cameron Diaz would have difficulty getting work. On what planet?

The best part of the DVD is the featurette about the elderly members of a retirement community who worked as extras for this film. I found myself genuinely moved when it was revealed that the man whose one line was "Me too" had passed away since the completion of the film.

If only the feature had been as moving.

Rescue from Gilligan's Island

Eleven years after the modest sitcom Gilligan's Island left the air, the television movie Rescue from Gilligan's Island was broadcast. It is not a great movie. The jokes are largely lame and the physical comedy annoys. Tellingly, Tina Louise, who played Ginger Grant on Gilligan, did not participate. Her replacement for Rescue gives us reason to suspect that Louise was a master thespian.

Yet Rescue still astonishes. There is a moment of catharsis about 40 minutes into the film when the castaways reach Honolulu and step off their raft built of co-joined huts. The viewer realizes that he has been waiting his whole life to see this moment, and it satisfies.

Each castaway returns to his or her previous life and, via a clever plot device, Gilligan and the Skipper pay each of them a visit. The viewer watches in amazement as the Gilligan characters go about life on land like anyone else. They work jobs and they have friends. No one mentions coconut cream pie. The viewer wants it to go on forever.

Buy at all costs.

Here Come the Double Deckers! (1970)

If you grew up in the 70's, Saturday mornings meant watching such classic children's television shows as The Shazam!/Isis Hour (1975), Lance Link: Secret Chimp (1970) and Sigmund and the Sea Monsters (1973). While your caregiver(s) were sleeping off the effects of five days of mindless work, you were catered to by some of the greatest minds in children's television and advertising. Some have argued that your time might have been better spent in some cooperative physical activity in which you could have acquired valuable social skills and attuned your body to the physical world, but they probably never watched Here Come the Double Deckers (1970), the single greatest children's program ever to reach these shores.

The Double Deckers had a clubhouse in a junkyard in an actual double decker bus. They were English, which meant they were smart, and they could make up songs on the spot and sing them to illustrate important story points. Though one club member was black, he had all the same club privileges as the other members. They lived just outside London right at the end of the swinging 60's, the best place and time to be alive ever.

Though this show is not yet on DVD or VHS, you can purchase a 3-DVDr set of the entire series on eBay. The original source material is most likely a television broadcast, so some serious copyright laws are being broken, as well as your eBay user agreement, but what's your other option? To not watch the Double Deckers ever again? Bullshit!

Katherine (1975) TV

This 1975 TV movie showcased the burgeoning talents of Henry Winkler, who was already astonishing critics as Arthur Fonzarelli AKA "The Fonz" on TV's Happy Days, and Sissy Spacek, who would appear the following year in the popular Carrie. Spacek plays an upper-class American who travels to Guatemala and discovers injustice. She returns home to realize that there is just as much injustice in America "only it's more hidden." She decides to make a difference through radical bombings. Art Carney was nominated for an Emmy for his naturalistic portrait of a father unable to understand his daughter or her bomb-making.

Unfortunately, Katherine is only available at the 99 cent store on an illegal Digiview Productions DVD or as a used VHS tape on Amazon. It is well worth spending every free day you have to find it.

The Muppet Christmas Carol

On November 29, The Muppet Christmas Carol will finally be available on DVD. Muppets fans and children everywhere are saying It's about fuckin time! There was a DVD produced in 2002, but it was a fullscreen pan-and-scan version. The new DVD will contain the widescreen theatrical release of TMCC and the fullscreen home video version, which had an additional musical number. Confusingly comprehensive!

This 1992 retelling of the Dickens classic wowed critics and viewers and demonstrated that the Muppets were still in top form despite the death of Jim Henson, the Disney buyout and the rising anti-puppetry movement. There is a reason why the Chinese government will not allow their citizens access to Muppet DVDs and why the The Muppet Movie is so hot on their black market. The Muppets are about individual expression and the freedom to be who you are. As they say in China, 它不是容易是綠色的 (It's Not Easy Bein' Green).

Hogan's Heroes Season 2 - The Wait Is Over

We have written here before about the groundbreaking TV series Hogan's Heroes. Season 1 showed us how far a brilliant concept and top-notch acting and directing could take a TV series. Season 2 demonstrates what happens when talented people know they are onto something great and proceed to take it up a notch. During my all-night viewing session, I was blown away by the sheer brilliance of Bob Crane, Werner Klemperer, Richard Dawson and company. When Hogan and Klink are together, the screen absolutely sizzles. Ouch. It's that hot. Rent at your own risk.

Why Movies Matter

Movies matter now more than ever. Today, when real world narratives no longer make sense, film (and to some extent, written) narratives are our only resource for meaning. For example, it is still possible to see a humorous story in film in 2005, whereas, in the external world, irony remains the sole modus humorous. Melodrama, though rare today in film, is still possible. By contrast, there are no more real world melodramas; there are only tragedies.

We recommend rewatching Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory, then comparing it to the recent failed remake.

Grey Gardens

If you think you have an unhealthy relationship with your mother (or you live with someone who you think ruined your life but you can't leave them until they die or you kill them), just watch Grey Gardens and you'll feel much much better. You and your friends can wonder Who is more crazy: Big Edie, Little Edie, or me? Make sure to watch the credits until the very very end, because there's a little surprise for fans and for those too drunk to get up and turn off the DVD player.

Alan Smithee felt sorry for Eugene.

Sigmund and the Sea Monsters (1973)

I'm not one to throw the word masterpiece around like candy, but SATSM broke so much new ground, it made the rest of the Saturday morning shows look like dog shit. Billy Barty astonishes as Sigmund Ooze, the sea monster who could not (or would not?) scare. And did we really know how a sea monster moved before Sharon Baird performed Big Daddy Ooze to perfection (his voice was provided by a variety of different performers)? Thankfully, this series is out on DVD, so now I have something to do every night this week.

Kung Fu - featuring David Carradine

Kung Fu came out of left field. TV viewers across the nation asked themselves "What the fuck is this?" If you watched Kung Fu in its original run, and if you are truly honest with yourself, you have to admit that 90% of your world view was formed by Caine's philosophy. It is unclear whether this is a testament to the writers of Kung Fu or the emptiness of modern American life.

Hogan's Heroes (1965 - 1971)

Critics over the years have tried to understand why Hogan's Heroes was such an influential TV series. The brilliant camera work and expert acting have long been acknowledged, but what has gone largely unmentioned was that Hogan's was the first TV series to seamlessly combine humor and drama. The horrors of the Nazi era are depicted right beside the humorous fumblings of Sgt. Schultz and Col. Klink.

A full seven years later, MASH would successfully copy this formula. MASH was widely praised, and rightfully so, but the recent release of Hogan's on DVD shows what critics have insisted over the years: Hogan's was an astonishingly innovative series whose impact is still being realized today.

Little known fact: Shakespearean actor Werner Klemperer was the son of the Jewish-German conductor Otto Klemperer and his contract specified that Colonel Klink could never be portrayed as a "good guy," and that the Nazis could never come out on top in any episode. Additionally, Robert Clary (LeBeau) had survived internment at Buchenwald.

Fawlty Towers - the Sir Nikolas Review

Sir Nikolas' blog offers succinct DVD reviews in addition to thoughtful poetry about the natural world. In his review of Fawlty Towers, Sir Nikolas said, in part:

It is (and will probly always be) the best Comidie series of all time. I strongly reccomend it. Manuel and Mr.Fawlty are a great combination that almost everyone can enjoy.